General Forums >> Ask a Firefighter >> steel

0

steel

143 Views
22 Replies Flag as inappropriate
Aundrea_lopez_007_250x200_max50

93 posts

back to top

Posted about 1 month ago

 

At what amount of degrees does burning steel start to collaspe in a building? Or is it just based on time and consistency with the fire?

Fire_school_005_max50

87 posts

 

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

The melting point of steel is between 1100 and 1600 degrees, but building materials can be covered on various other materials and coatings so it all kind of depends. You've posted a lot of random questions, you could try looking in a firefighting textbook or even trying the Google searchbar on for try.

Spock_max50

1549 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

depends on the steel alloy, folks.  chromium steel vs. titanium or magnesium or carbon steel?  pre-existing asbestos fireproofing sprayed on or not?  (some of the substitute fireproofing works just as well, actually.)  this is a hard question to answer.  my perspective is that if the structural steel is already on fire, back away and use remote hose-holders or monitor nozzles, as per the DOT Emergency Response Guidebook.  does that make any sense, or am i too uninitiated here on this particular topic?

L_dfe3f3b2bdbfde30fa8980ef34c6ae42_max50

773 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

FieryRedHead says ...



The melting point of steel is between 1100 and 1600 degrees, but building materials can be covered on various other materials and coatings so it all kind of depends. You've posted a lot of random questions, you could try looking in a firefighting textbook or even trying the Google searchbar on for try.



look at miss.know-it-all here!  j/k   :P


when we were in the bedroom at the academy you were like miss.dictionary when I would ask you questions because of all the studying you've been doing! kinda like gwyd....I dunno if you watch law and order:ci, but gwyd, your like detective goran on there....you seem to know everything about anything! lol

Spock_max50

1549 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

or i'm like Inspector Gadget, but the kind of gadget you find in the bad part of town, double-D batteries required, LOL!  i don't claim to know it all, i just soak up info like a sponge so i can share it with everybody else!  i learn new stuff every time i teach a class.

Fire_school_005_max50

87 posts

 

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Weigl says ...



FieryRedHead says ...



The melting point of steel is between 1100 and 1600 degrees, but building materials can be covered on various other materials and coatings so it all kind of depends. You've posted a lot of random questions, you could try looking in a firefighting textbook or even trying the Google searchbar on for try.



look at miss.know-it-all here!  j/k   :P


when we were in the bedroom at the academy you were like miss.dictionary when I would ask you questions because of all the studying you've been doing! kinda like gwyd....I dunno if you watch law and order:ci, but gwyd, your like detective goran on there....you seem to know everything about anything!


I'm such a huge fire geek, I'm glad I could answer your questions though. Hit me up periodically and I know it is only going to get worse. What else are you supposed to talk about in fire academy dorms other than fire loser girl stuff? That was so much fun, I wish we could have girls only sleepover/fire training weekends at the fire academy more often :-)


And Gwyd...quit reading books and stuff, you make the rest of us sound uneducated. :-p


 


Fire_school_005_max50

87 posts

 

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

^^^ I don't know how all of that up there ended up in a quote. I'm sure you can differentiate what you all said from what I did.

Frog_pic_max50

815 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Gwyd says ...



depends on the steel alloy, folks.  chromium steel vs. titanium or magnesium or carbon steel?  pre-existing asbestos fireproofing sprayed on or not?  (some of the substitute fireproofing works just as well, actually.)  this is a hard question to answer.  my perspective is that if the structural steel is already on fire, back away and use remote hose-holders or monitor nozzles, as per the DOT Emergency Response Guidebook.  does that make any sense, or am i too uninitiated here on this particular topic?


This is what the book says and a liitle more if your able to decipher it all. Your profile says your a recruit- are you in class now? This is a question that that is answered in Fire Essentials book maybe not as detailed as Gwyd's answer but then again what is!
And Gywd, Weigl got it so right on the Detective Goran. I had an ex who used to call me the book of useless facts... I don't even compare in knowledge of my know little of everything- can't master a thing!

L_dfe3f3b2bdbfde30fa8980ef34c6ae42_max50

773 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

YAH, a fellow law and order fan!!!


At first I thought he seemed like Det. Munch from SVU, but I think Goran is definitaly a better fit!


And I guess you'll just have to start watching to find out Gwyd! :P

Spock_max50

1549 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Well, Froog, i never watched any of those shows but i'll trust Weigl's judgement.  i was once called a "font of useless knowledge," but in my opinion there's no such thing...it all comes in handy sooner or later, and often in the weirdest of circumstances.


i just like learning new stuff, and that helps when i teach refresher classes, because otherwise students are bored to tears hearing the same old shit year after year.  the "mad scientist" attitude helps as well.  if i can't make it different every year, their snores would keep ME awake!

Frog_pic_max50

815 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Know what you mean... I once started a hour long vocal dissertation on the several different species of racoons- yeah I know who cares! But you know it just might come in handy if I ever get over my camera stage fright and get a spot on Jeopardy.

Hpim0549_max50

62 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Steel beams and heavy structural members can go up 1200-1300 degrees before failing, but the lighter steel roof trusses will start twisting and failing as low as 900-1000. The thickness and amount of surface area exposed to the heat plays a big roll, as well as, like GWYD said, the type and treatment of the steel members. This is where preplanning comes very much into play, KNOW THINE ENEMY !

Pfc_schmidt1_max50

258 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Gwyd, Iike your picture of Spock you have for your avatar. Very intersting! I'm a Trek fan myself.


"Semper Fi Do or Die" United States Marine Corps

Picture_036_max50

1220 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Gwyd says ...



depends on the steel alloy, folks.  chromium steel vs. titanium or magnesium or carbon steel?  pre-existing asbestos fireproofing sprayed on or not?  (some of the substitute fireproofing works just as well, actually.)  this is a hard question to answer.  my perspective is that if the structural steel is already on fire, back away and use remote hose-holders or monitor nozzles, as per the DOT Emergency Response Guidebook.  does that make any sense, or am i too uninitiated here on this particular topic?



Nah. Your perspective is about right. I don't care to get under steel that's on fire either.

Pfc_schmidt1_max50

258 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

I've been in a structure fire and I saw the steel beams starting to bend. Did not like that sight at all. It was bowing at the center, I was afraid the walls it was supporting were going to collapse.


"Semper Fi Do or Die" United States Marine Corps

Firescue_max50

272 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Steel melts at 2750 degrees Farenheit.


Steel loses 50% of its strenght at 1100°F and at 1800°F it has less than 10%.


Steel begins to lose its ability to support its own weight between 500 to 900°F


As steel is heated it begins to enlongate and push out the side of buildings weaking the structaral integrity of the building.  If it can't elongate it twists, sags, and bends.


Some fuels and temperatures for comparison are:  typical structure fire generates temperatures between 700 to 2000°F,   LPG ignites between  920-1029°F and  Optimum Flame Temperature is 3500°F, and  Jet fuel burns at 800° to 1500°F

Spock_max50

1549 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

i so need to get a camera.  at the Praxair site, 2 blocks from where i teach, where about 8000 cylinders of acetylene, propylene, and propane went off in 2005, you can still see where all sorts of pipes turned into spaghetti.  i have a photo album devoted to the site, but it doesn't show that.  how much is a digital cam these days?

Frog_pic_max50

815 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

You can pick up a decent one around $100 bucks. I'd be interested in seeing those pics

L_dfe3f3b2bdbfde30fa8980ef34c6ae42_max50

773 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

eBay!

Spock_max50

1549 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

yeah, OK, eBay, but they don't trust me with plastic.  you'd hafta go make the buy for me as if it was a drug deal.

L_dfe3f3b2bdbfde30fa8980ef34c6ae42_max50

773 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Eh, no money! I just bought myself a new phone off their. XV6700, my hubs has one now and I love it! If hacked right, it's basically a mini-laptop! But without having to pay the $40 a month data plan. They screw ya anyway they can :(

Spock_max50

1549 posts

back to top
0

Rated 0 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

hmmm...pyramid schemes, eh?  i only wanted to get a cam to take some pics of me, since i don't have any, and people seem to want to find out what the hell i look like.  i'll need a 'puter too, when i move out of this dump.