General Forums >> How To Become A Firefighter >> color blindness

+2

color blindness

275 Views
29 Replies Flag as inappropriate
Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top

Posted 3 months ago

 

I have looked through in the archives, and found nothing about this, so im looking for any info anyone has any info that will help me.  I have been bustin my ass, practicing for the pat, getting ready for the written test, and going to the gym 6 days a week all while working 6days a week because all i want to  do is become a firefighter, now i find out that colorblindness disqualifies me apperently, at least it does with the dept i was getting ready to test for.  Is there a certain degree or something of colorblindness that disqualifies me, or is it just a cut and dry, youre color blind so youre out kind of thing?  any help at all anyone can shoot me would be greatly appreciated, seeing as if its just a cut and dry kind of thing i have just wasted the past 8 months, and would like to avoid wasting more time if i cannot get my dream.

Fire_academy_haz_mat_tech_2008_013edit__medium__max50

406 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

I dont know if this helps any brother, but Ive been a firefighter for 20 years and Im colorblind.  I have no problems with my colorblindness and detecting bad situations in fires, I can read the smoke, I can read the fire without colors.  You should approach the chief, or whoever is in charge of the testing and hiring, and ask them exactly why that disqualifies you and if you can challenge it at least.  You might be able to get by without worrying about it, but you never know unless you ask someone.  And dont stop there, if you are not happy with his/her answer than ask who their boss is and talk to them next, go through the channels and talk to as many people as you can, you might find either your answer or a free pass to take the test...who knows! lol


Good luck and keep us posted.


Brian "Moose" Jones
Firefighter II / EMT-D
Haz-Mat Technician
Nationaly Cerified Fire Investigator
NYS Codes Officer
"Amatuers train until they get it right, professionals train until they cant get it wrong."

Photo_user_blank_big

20 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

I'm agreeing with Moose here on this one i have never heard that im color blind and have been al of my life and i never had a problem...

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

see, thats what i dont understand, this department, on thier list of minimum requirements, states that an applicant must have vision correctable to 20 20, and free of color blindness, kind of discriminatory if you ask me, as long as it doesnt hurt the way i perform or hinders poses a hazard, which it doesnt, then whats the problem, right?  maybe they are just pickier than other departments.  thanks so much guys!!!!!  i was hoping i would see responses like this.  I have contacted by phone and email, the firm handling the applications and what not for the department, and the same with the department, so far no answer, i guess they cant explain why that would disqualify me.  Thier loss! im gonna make some department proud as hell to have me.  I dont give up very easily.  thanks again guys!!!

Photo_user_blank_big

20 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

I hope everything works out well for you Grind and as always watch you back out there brother

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

maybe i am missing something in what i am reading, if ya get bored and want to take a look at it, let me know, il send ya a msg with the website, i may be pissed at them but im not gonna drag them out in public, they are still firefighters. :)

5d97_max50

256 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

I asked our saftey officer about this and he said to his knowledge there is no reg dealing with color blindness. as long as it did'nt hamper your ability to do your job safley then there should'nt be a problem

Photo_user_blank_big

20 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

then what do you have for me Brother

5d97_max50

256 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

firefighter301 says ...



then what do you have for me Brother



i wish you lived up here,we're looking for a couple of good firefighters to fill some open slots we'd take ya in a heart beat

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

you and me both steven :)  i dont give up though, so if i dont get in here in illinois, i will be relocating somewhere.  they can kill my good mood, but they are not gonna kill my dream.

5d97_max50

256 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

i will keep looking into this as well as my safety officer. dig out the nfpa's and see what we can find out

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

thank you so much steven, you have no idea how much i appreciate all the help i am getting from you all on the site.  I looked into NFPA 1582 and the only thing i found about color blindness is if it is so bad that it prevents you from being able to use imaging devices.  again, thank you so much!!! i am sure you have other things to do in your free time, i really appreciate it!!

5d97_max50

256 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

no problem brother thats what this site is all about! take care

Fire_academy_haz_mat_tech_2008_013edit__medium__max50

406 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

Keep going grind, never give up, never surrender!!! lol  Good luck to you and keep us posted.  You should call these people and not E-mail them though...keep calling and calling every day and do not give them a day to breath, eventually they will respond.  GOOD LUCK!


Moose


Brian "Moose" Jones
Firefighter II / EMT-D
Haz-Mat Technician
Nationaly Cerified Fire Investigator
NYS Codes Officer
"Amatuers train until they get it right, professionals train until they cant get it wrong."

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

im not gonna give up moose, i called fd today and thier answer was for me to refer any questions i had about the position to public safety recruitment, the firm handling the applications and stuff for them, that was real helpful, the guy was a total jerkoff about it too.   So, i contacted the firm, who in turn contacted the fire department for an answer (they couldnt have just given me the dam answer?) and was told "Unfortunately, it is stated in the minimum requirements for the  blah blah fire department (name withheld to protect the stupid) that all applicants must be free of any color blindness" and that "the rules the department must abide by are the rules set by the comission"  that made absolutely no sence to me, i think i would have gotten a better answer from my dog! I am going to stop in at my local dept tomorrow and ask them about it, since the dept i wanted to apply at and the firm handling the process could not give me a straight answer, they wouldnt even elaborate on exactly what disqualifies me.  A couple friends of mine have buddies that are firefighters, in illinois, that are colorblind,  they too have never heard of this.  Its ok, the more i have to deal with this peticular dept, the more i think i wouldnt want to work for them any dam way.  my dept is out there somewhere, if i have to move to find it, so be it.  thanks again for all the help and you guys lookin into this.

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
+2

Rated: +2 | Posted 3 months ago

 

YES!!!!!!!! now thats what i call a victory boys and girls!!!!!!!!!!!  if it wouldnt get flagged, id post a vid of me dancing a naked jig on a ladder with a weight pack on my back!  I went to the illinois fire chiefs association website today, looked around, made some phone calls, and made some phone calls to other fire departments here, even though they are not currently hiring, and all except the one i was originally going to test for said that the only vision requirements were obvoiusley that i had to have good enough vision, which is a given, i knew that one, but the cherry on the bananna split was that they ALL said (except for the crap town fd) that as far as color,  the only standard they require is that i meet requirements specified by nfpa 1582, which says as long as i can use imaging devices, i pass.  i have thermal imaging equip, and infrared equip, and use it without any problem seeing things whatsoever.  the thing with the town i was going to test for is only because they can all apperently adjust the standards of what they want, with in reason of course.  So it is not an illinois thing, its not a county thing, it is only a municipality thing.  :)   :)  Y'all know what that means right?  i keep bustin my ass training and practicing, and learning, and wait for a dept to be hiring, and im in, as long as i pass everything of course.   I'm sure you can all relate to how friggin happy this has made me, im man enough to admit that i am sitting here typing this, listening to the ladder 49 soundtrack, and crying like a little 6 year old girl, with a BIIIIIIG smile on my face.  :)

Firefighter_chicks_max50

1371 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

Hahaha CONGRATS!!!!! That's awesome, GOOD LUCK!!!



No one can make you feel inferior without your consent.

Fire_academy_haz_mat_tech_2008_013edit__medium__max50

406 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

CONGRATULATIONS BROTHER!!!!!!!  Way to keep at it and get the info you needed, now good luck on finding that job and let me know if you need any help with tests and practicals, Id be glad to help.  GOOD JOB!!!!!!!!!!!!


Brian "Moose" Jones
Firefighter II / EMT-D
Haz-Mat Technician
Nationaly Cerified Fire Investigator
NYS Codes Officer
"Amatuers train until they get it right, professionals train until they cant get it wrong."

Firescue_max50

553 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

If I have read this correctly, you have attempted to talk with the Fire department whose hiring policy states that being colorblind disqualifies you from the hiring process?   If this is true go to the policy makers, the city council or city manager and have then explain this policy to you!  I would ask to be put on the agenda for the next meeting and ask them in open forum WHY!  I would contact the press and have them there too.  If you can perform the all of duties of a Firefighter, then this is a discriminating policy. 


Firefighters put the Wet stuff on the Red stuff and Policy is created by bureaucrats to perpetuate the process.


Eddie D. Howard
6th Grade Dodgeball Champion
Duck, Duck, Goose Runner-Up

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

yes reven, youre reading that correctly, i kind of thought it was discriminatory too, but i am not a firefighter yet and i am still learning how things work,  i figured that if i made a big stink about this, that it would bite me in the butt.  But thats a hell of an idea, i will dig in and find out who makes the rules for the municipality in reagards to being a firefighter, and go to the village hall to talk to them in person,  im sure they wont have a problem explaining to me EXACTLY what disqualifies me even if i pass all the tests and interview yada yada yada.  I've got half a mind to test for this dept anyway, then blow them away with what someone my size is able to do,  but i am going to see what kind of information i get from the village on the regs. first, and go from there.  thanks again, i had not thought of that, man ive got alot to learn ;) 

100_0738_max50

44 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

I would say its a dept policy thing and i find it kind of silly i would say red blue is the only thing that would disqualify i dont see how the others would.

Photo_user_blank_big

390 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

Get a Lawyer.

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted 3 months ago

 

i was thinking about it jim, but i was digging around on the internet and found that at least here in illinois, municipalities and villages can with in reason add to the regs  and requirements as they see fit, and coming from chicago, the city where politics reign supreme, if i made a big stink about this, i could easily see myself blackballed or some off the wall crap, probably a little overdramatic on my part, i admit it. but i am not prepared to risk my dream just to stick it to one department.  the way i see it, i will dig and get the answer i want as to why i get disqualified, and then i will wait until i find another dept that is testing and make them proud to have me. the funny thing about it is that whether i call the village mayor, manager, or the fire department directly, noone can give me a straight answer as to why.  too many dam politicians ;)   


  and yeah doolittle, as long as i can see red and blue, and put the wet stuff on the red stuff (thank you raven) that it is silly, but it is thier policy appernatly, but it is also thier loss!! ;)  i am going to make some dept dam proud to have me, just wont be this one.

Accident_020_max50

80 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 3 months ago

 

I'm happy everything is working out for you!


The measure of life, after all, is not its duration, but its donation.

Photo_user_blank_big

13 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 2 months ago

 

 


Posting from the internet:


 


I just wanted to drop this web site by,  it is in regards to color vision.  I was recently disqualified from the San Diego fire academy for failing my medical Exam.  I failed because I was unable to pass the color vision tests they gave me.  I appealed  the disqualification and did many hours of research on color deficiency and in my research I came across like the colormax lens.  Contact lens called Chromagen lens that are FDA approved.  I contacted an ophthalmologist that is proved on there web site and was able to get a prescription to correct my color vision.  I was able to pass 100% both color vision tests the ishihara and Farnsworth. I was able to retest with the city and passed the color vision part of the medical exam.  The total cost for the Doctors visit and prescription was appox. $600.00.  If this can help any one else with color deficiency I would highly recommend it.


 


Web Site:  http://www.chromagen-international.com/chromagen/index2_ingles.htm


 


Jeremy


 


 


Ok, According to the EEOC and ADA if you can't pass the color test given, but the doctor asks you to identify basic colors IE Red, Green, and Blue etc. You have to show that even though you cant pass the test you will still be able to perform the basic job duties, by being able to tell these basic colors. You just need to articulate to them they you can perform the basic job duties of identifying the colors of cars and clothing descriptions. POST has also said that if an applicant fails the test, but can id the basics he/she is fine. or if it came down to it, but don’t recommend you can get the x chrome contact lenses which is a couple of hundred dollars.  The lenses don’t enable you to see colors, but changes them so you can identify them.


 


The test you took was the Ishihara plate test. Which it does tell a Dr. that you are colorblind. The bad thing about this test is unfair for people with a slight colorblindness, since the Ishihara plates are deliberately artificial images, and do not represent the range of colors that people see in everyday life. I had this problem with my agency. Ask them for another option. Ask if you can go and have a Farnsworth D15 test. This test will show how severe your colorblindness is. You will have to pay for it your self. Do keep in mind that some agencies will DQ you for being colorblind no matter what. Good luck and do not let this stop you going for what you want!


 


There are also sites online that offer the ishihara tests for free and you can use them to “study” what numbers you are supposed to see so you can pass the test. I know someone that did this, got hired and has had absolutely NO PROBLEMS at any point on the job (related to color vision that is). Is it cheating or unethical?..I’ll leave that up to you. Is it worth it to get your dream job? I think so, but that’s just me.


Fire "Captain Bob" www.eatstress.com

Biiig_fishy_max50

84 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 2 months ago

 

that is AWESOME spanner!!! the very same test is what my eye doc told me made me "slightly" colorblind, but unless it is for that stupid little test, i dont even notice it.  If i was in the position where i needed to get those contacts, or if someone else was in that same position, yeah, id say we would all spend the 600 bucks ;)  i guess some departments are just pickier than others. the town i live in has no problem with the color vision, as long as you can identify certain colors, just like you mentioned, wonder why i didnt talk to THEM first instead of looking outside my town for a ff position.  GLAD IT WORKED OUT FOR YOU!!!

Jason_526_max50

19 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 2 months ago

 

I'm not for sure do not quote me on this...


 


If you are on a volunteer fire department then the colorblindness reg is not valid, but I do not know for sure..

0 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 2 months ago

 

Why is the hiring process for a FD left up to a board that has little or no knowledge of FD policy?  I applied many years ago to a dept, they liked me and we all got along. My app got to the commission and was rejected because, are you ready?  I got a speeding ticket 5 years before.  Not reckless or DUI but a 10 over in a 55 zone speeding ticket.  I didn't fight it.  Why would I want to work for a city that nit-picks EVERYTHING?  One of their guys got hurt, the city paid etc, etc.  He came back to work ready and able. He was promtly fired as a "liability". Not the dept, the commission.


Civil action pending.  Glad they turned me down. 


Point is, this stupidity happens everywhere.

412cunningham01_max50

33 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 2 months ago

 

Sorry to hear that.  I am color blind as well...  It was never brought out throughout my hiring process at my dept.  I would say some where down the line there was a issue at the particular deptment over the issue.  So they had to write a rule for it to cover thereself...  Not necesarily the right thing to do but it solved the issue.  I wouldn't give up though.  For every one deptment that has that rule there are 20 that don't.  If worst comes to worst my deptment is hiring 3-4 guys in Oct-Nov.  With probally about 16 over the next 3 years to help feel Station #6.  If your interested here is the web site: www.joplinmofire.org.  Best of luck.